|


















| |

Reprinted from The Syracuse
Astronomical Society, The Astronomical Chronicle © December 2002 with permission
from Stu Forster.
|
No matter what style of
telescope you use, you need to have some way of aiming it Instruments with
wide fields of view require a rough alignment to get you into the general
vicinity of your target, while higher powered, longer focal length scopes
with narrower fields of view require more sophisticated aiming devices.
Finders can be divided into three general classes:
1. Line of sight
2. Zero power/reflex
3. Small telescopes.
Line of sight finders are basically variations of mechanical gunsights.
They can be as simple as a cardboard tube or straw attached to the scope or
be a little more sophisticated and have V-notches to align with a pointer to
aid in aiming. These units are overall lightweight, inexpensive, but they
work with wide-field instruments such as binoculars and the Astroscan from
Edmund Scientific and its' clones.
Zero power/reflex sights all use LEDs. They all project an image on an
optical window, have variable brightness, and can be divided into three
general groups.
1. Red dot
2. Rigel Quickfinder
3. Telrad
Red dot finders are just that, they project a red dot on a window that is
aligned with the object of interest. All zero power finders are best used
with both eyes open. This speeds acquiring the target and decreases
parallax. Their attributes are low price, light weight and simplicity. The
original red dot finders were modified BB gun sights and had small fields of
view. Apogee recently released a wide-field red dot finder with a 9 degree
field of view. It also can be used in either red or green dot. Its' price
has also been dropped to $21.95, which is a bargain even with shipping.
These finders work great with the Short Tube 80mm F-5 rich field scopes sold
by many vendors under numerous names. One shortcoming is the use of watch
batteries whose replacement costs can add up over time.
The Rigel Quickfinder is a step up from the red dot finders, and are full
featured in a small package. The Quickfinder reticle consists of two
concentric circles, with the inner having a diameter of ½ degree, and the
outer two degrees. The Rigel unit is lightweight, at 3.3 ounces and stands
tall to allow easy use on giant binoculars and small scopes. Although its'
battery will last a long time, it's a specialized watch battery like the
ones in the red dot finders, and can be expensive to keep replacing if
you're forgetful in turning it off at the end of a viewing session. The
Rigel units contain one feature that is not available on red dots and are
available at extra cost on Telrads. This is a Pulsar system, where the LED
will blink on and off to allow acquisition of dim targets. The interval in
which the LED stays on as well as the time it's off is adjustable. Price of
this unit runs about $30 at discounters.
The third zero power finder
is also the most popular, the Telrad. This is a reflex style, where a
reticle is projected on an optical window which is at a 45 degree angle to
the line of sight. This arrangement makes it appear as if the reticle
pattern is actually being projected on the sky. The Telrad's reticle has
three concentric circles, encompassing ½ degree, two degrees and four
degrees. The Telrad is heavier than the Rigel, at 11 ounces. The Telrad uses
AA batteries which seem to last forever, even if you are forgetful and leave
the unit on for a week. Options for the Telrad include a Pulsar unit and a
dewshield. Most star atlases, including digital ones have provisions for
placing Telrad circles around targets to aid in acquisition. There are also
some guide books, such as the Sky Spot series from Brent Watson that are
specifically dedicated to using a Telrad. Harvard Pennington's "Year Round
Messier Marathon" book also is A Telrad dedicated book and should be in all
amateur's reference libraries.
One problem that plagues all the LED finders is dew. Dewshields are
available for the Telrad, and depending on design range from marginally to
very effective. The unit supplied by the manufacturer for $10-12 is
worthless in my opinion. The Astrosystem's unit for about $18 works well.
Adding a Dewheater strip from Kendrick Studios is probably the best way to
go. A second problem with reflex finders is that they don't work well in
bright skies. Since they don't gather light, you can't locate and center dim
stars.
The third type of finders consist of small telescopes. The first number
refers to the power, the second to the diameter of the objective or light
gathering lens. Until recently the most common type of these finders were
straight through viewing, with the image turned upside down and flipped left
to right. Recently right angle versions appeared which can be more
comfortable to view from at certain angles. These usually give an image that
is correct vertically, but flipped right to left. Correct image finders with
either 45 degree or 90 degree diagonals are also now commonly available. The
big problem with erecting prism diagonals in the optical train is the loss
of light that can be encountered with additional reflections. The positive
attributes are the ease of use, and usually more comfortable viewing
position. When it comes to mounting brackets, those with two rings and six
point adjustments (three on each ring)have also been the preferred design.
Recently some brackets with two adjustment screws and a spring loaded
plunger at the site of the third screw have become available. The other ring
has a rubber O-ring to fix it in place in a stable fashion. These are
actually easy to adjust and hold their adjustments quite well. The higher
the power, the smaller the field of view. They can be grouped into the
following types:
1. 5x24
2. 6x26/6x30 - inverted and correct image
3. 8x50/9x60
4. Giant finders - 80mm and up
The 5x24 finders are included with many beginner scopes. There are two words
that can be used sum up their quality and usefulness - TRASH and GARBAGE.
Unfortunately these finders have major shortcomings that have probably
dissuaded more newbies from further pursuing the hobby than the shaky mounts
and poor quality eyepieces that are included as original equipment with
beginner scopes from department stores. If you can find it, you can't
observe it, and these units are deemed for failure from the start. To begin
with many of the more recently manufactured units have PLASTIC objective
lenses. Those that are manufactured from glass are simple lenses, not
achromats. What's the big deal? They can't focus all colors of light to the
same point of focus, so there is a color fringe around all bright stars. To
combat this, the manufacturers place a plastic annulus of small diameter in
mid barrel to correct this chromatic aberration. Unfortunately this also
blocks half the diameter of the objective and you end up with not much more
aperture than your naked eye with a fully dilated 7mm pupil. A simple sight
tube with a cross hair would work just as well. Add to this a poor quality
mounting bracket that is easily knocked out of alignment, narrow field of
view and you have all the ingredients for major frustration. Bottom line, if
you have a scope with one of these finders, plan on replacing it ASAP.
The next size larger are the 6x26 and 6x30 finders. These are usually of
higher quality, although there are still some with non achromatic objective
lenses. These will show some larger globular clusters and usually have
higher quality mounting brackets. The erect image versions are usually the
6x26 versions. They will collect less light than the 6x30's, but are a
little easier to use. These are light years better than the 5x24's. They
cost any where from $35-50 with brackets. They are available for half that
used on Astromart.
Far better and much more practical than the 30mm finders are the 50 and 60mm
sizes. These will penetrate to deeper magnitudes and tend to come with
sturdy mounts. Some also have the ability to add an illuminator for the
crosshairs which makes precise centering of faint objects possible. The
illuminated 7x50 Takahashi finder I use for centering guide stars for CCD
imaging is capable of getting the star centered on the chip due to its'
excellent reticle design and the illuminated crosshairs. These will cost
anywhere from $45-75 with brackets, but once again can be found on Astromart
for half that , especially if you're willing to accept a few scratches from
adjustment screws.
Finally there are the giant finders. These are of 80mm and larger size and
are great for locating faint objects and large objects with low surface
brightness, such as M 33, the Helix and the Rosette nebulae. These require
heavier mounting hardware such as the rings and mounting from Losmandy. In
addition they may require additional counterweights on the scopes. |
|